Same Topic but Different Language

[Agios 1763]

If we want to create a new post, after getting the title, then we must first use Search, to find out if there are the same topics, if we can get the same topic but use a different language, whether this is allowed or will be deleted. What do you think?.

[Ajlovez7 594]

I think it will be allowed because take mine example, i don't understand Russian language so i m not understanding that topics , so if anyone like you could write the topic in English same topic, it would be really helpful for members like me and community.

[spyaquino 907]

I am favorable in not having many topics with similar subjects, as I said similar, because if they were equal would be plagiar right. But on the other hand freedom of writing must exist, if in any language whatsoever, I think each topic is valid as long as it is not a copy or plagiarism of another.

[Agios 1763]

10 minutes ago, Cris said:

You have a point, I think it will be allowed since we cannot understand their Language like Russian, it will be good if we have a section that are base on our local language.

Thank you for your information, this is a problem that I often met, if I already have a title posts and do a Search, there are often similarities in Russian, and I translate Russian to English on Google translate, and the contents are almost the same with different language styles. so I always hesitate to publish / post.

[Agios 1763]

11 minutes ago, Sujon33 said:

Same topic in this forum should be deleted.Before post a topic you can search because duplicate topic break our forum community discipline.So every membe should need search topic before posting 

I have also used Search, but the problem is the difference between Russian and English. So it's not an aduplicate topic / copy paste. Although the topic is the same, the ways of explanation and conclusion are also different.

[lakhlomoha 485]

The same topic with other language i think it's good and not out of rules of the forum,but the problems is the language we have just English and Russian in this forum 

[I-KUN 422]

yeah it will be counted as copy/paste topics right ? but i think it won't be a problem if the topic was posted by the same person. maybe he translated into english version, so people who can't speak russians can join the discussions.

[Agios 1763]

1 hour ago, Rafbouk said:

In my opinion it should be allowed as long as you don’t speak Russian. There are only two languages here in this forum ( English, Russian) it’s up to moderators/ admin to accept or think its duplicate as I’m sure they all speak Russian. If you post  in both English and Russian that’s pretty obvious and easy to spot. 

Thanks for your opinion, I don't know Russian, only with the help of Google translate, I know what that means. Although the topic and title are almost the same, but the explanation is very different.

[teminalibug 309]

13 hours ago, Agios said:

If we want to create a new post, after getting the title, then we must first use Search, to find out if there are the same topics, if we can get the same topic but use a different language, whether this is allowed or will be deleted. What do you think?.

If same topic different languages i think there is nothing wrong about that, it gives opportunities for people of different language to contribute.

[Agios 1763]

1 hour ago, Dada said:

Even with the same language there is a lot of same or duplicated topics that circles the forum so i think it will not matter if you do have the same topic in the different language section, but if you can try to post a new and fresh topic it will be much better.

Ok. thanks for your advice. I also see a lot of topics that are almost the same in the same language (English), although maybe it's okay, but I still hesitate to publish (post). I'm also looking for new topics for the same content.

1 hour ago, teminalibug said:

If same topic different languages i think there is nothing wrong about that, it gives opportunities for people of different language to contribute.

Thanks, mate for your opinion/advice. but I'm trying to change the words on the topic and content.

[hafizafather 15]

On 11/14/2019 at 12:36 AM, Yukiyuki said:

I will agree to this because a lot of us here is not comfortable using english because in their country english isn't their second language even its our international language its really difficult for them to speak and understand english. 

I agree with you bro.. English language is number 2 in my country.. So.. Sometimes i do mistake when i posts with English

 

[Kimmy So 176]

i saw some comments that are using their local language. hopefully, the administrators  would take into consider about having the different local language sections.

[fajarriadi 179]

On 11/13/2019 at 11:53 PM, Agios said:

If we want to create a new post, after getting the title, then we must first use Search, to find out if there are the same topics, if we can get the same topic but use a different language, whether this is allowed or will be deleted. What do you think?.

In my view, there is no need to delete the similar topic in different language. The reason is this forum are used by the user from various country. Not all of them fluent in languages that available here. If we want to write a new topic but we see the similar topic with different language, we still can continue it but we have to add more information there so we can avoid the plagiarism. 

[Agios 1763]

1 hour ago, Awaremooner said:

The topic of your post got me thinking there are people from both section posts same topic in the two sections in different languages. This your topic is more or less talking about duplicated posts and you are also guilty of the same offence you complaining about

Oh no, I'm not talking about duplicate posts but talking about Listening Radio Earn Cryptocurrency. So I need to postpone publishing / post and make improvements to the wording in English.

[maricans 401]

On 11/14/2019 at 12:53 AM, Agios said:

If we want to create a new post, after getting the title, then we must first use Search, to find out if there are the same topics, if we can get the same topic but use a different language, whether this is allowed or will be deleted. What do you think?.

If same member post it in two language i think it can be consider spamming, but if two member post it in two language i think it can be consider duplicate topic.

[Agios 1763]

19 minutes ago, maricans said:

If same member post it in two language i think it can be consider spamming, but if two member post it in two language i think it can be consider duplicate topic.

Not 2 members' posts in two languages, but the topic / title is the same or similar, of course the discussion is different, and I forced it to be published but soon the post was deleted without warning.

[maricans 401]

22 hours ago, Agios said:

Not 2 members' posts in two languages, but the topic / title is the same or similar, of course the discussion is different, and I forced it to be published but soon the post was deleted without warning.

Just wondering, how come if same topic title (rules state that topic title should not be compose only of one or two words, as stated: https://cryptotalk.org/topic/207-general-rules-of-cryptotalkorg-forum-official/page/5/) but different discussion, aren't we are suppose to connect the 'Topic Title to Original post'.

 

Edited December 1, 2019 by maricans

[Agios 1763]

10 minutes ago, maricans said:

Just wondering, how come if same topic title (rules state that topic title should not be compose only of one or two words, as stated by moderator @epidemia:https://cryptotalk.org/topic/207-general-rules-of-cryptotalkorg-forum-official/page/5/) but different discussion, aren't we are suppose to connect the 'Topic Title to Original post'.

 

Want to know this is the title of the post that has been deleted "Listening Radio be Awarded" Contents discussing the topic of listening to the radio will get a free coin (BRO coin).

[maricans 401]

40 minutes ago, Agios said:

Want to know this is the title of the post that has been deleted "Listening Radio be Awarded" Contents discussing the topic of listening to the radio will get a free coin (BRO coin).

I think you can create another topic for it since it was deleted, just place it in the right section for it that will not be deleted for "off topic" reason. But i don't suggest you post it in two language.

Edited November 30, 2019 by maricans

[Gusion 321]

I think it is allowed if it is posted in your language section. In that way, you will have your countrymen help you about what your needs and understand in fully. Hoping I could get my language section too.

[Yanadia 1517]

The same topic with different languages still has the same meaning. Discussion of the same thing.  I disagree, but it will be confusing, especially for a newbie like me

[Muphin 459]

I don't think I understand you but I suggest a new section for different languages but that would be so many so let's just stick with English language since English is the International Language wherein people worldwide know how to speak and understand English.

[Raven 7817]

Yeah, i think there is no problem with it. There are many users here that has different language so i think admins and moderators will allowed it because this forum has many users that has different languages. That's what i think. 

[SyntaxEr. 709]

On 11/14/2019 at 12:53 AM, Agios said:

If we want to create a new post, after getting the title, then we must first use Search, to find out if there are the same topics, if we can get the same topic but use a different language, whether this is allowed or will be deleted. What do you think?.

I think this is not allowed because the content is the same the only difference is the language used so I suggest don't try to post with the same content. 

[xprince1996 865]

On 11/14/2019 at 12:53 AM, Agios said:

If we want to create a new post, after getting the title, then we must first use Search, to find out if there are the same topics, if we can get the same topic but use a different language, whether this is allowed or will be deleted. What do you think?.

It is a big NO because it is the same as a duplicate content. That's why it is better to search first the topic so that you won't get the same with the other topics.