Add Private Feedback Note for Members

[hexwin 4931]

3 minutes ago, dovproduc said:

Considering that there is no trading section yet, I don't see what that would be for. Maybe we should add new areas of the forum so people can do more stuff, and then add features like feedback

There is Marketplace section in cryptotalk forum where people can sell or buy stuff and services.
That can be something like trading, but I can use it for so many other things also

Edited October 18, 2019 by hexwin

[Cryptohash 702]

2 hours ago, hexwin said:

I would like if we can see option to write text feedback to specific members.
That would be much better than current reaction system.

If someone is good quality poster or if I traded with him, I want to write short text review.

If someone is non-stop spamming me with fake conversation spam - I also want to write review for his profile.

This idea is good and interesting. 

One accepts its other one deny's it and rest would be jealous seeing those post which can create more mood swings.

If you give a message leaving its spam that user may abuse feedback system very bad :).

[hexwin 4931]

2 minutes ago, Cryptohash said:

If you give a message leaving its spam that user may abuse feedback system very bad :).

You can NOT abuse the system very bad, because you awill not be posting public rfeedback, it will be private feedback that only you can see

[xBDT Script 4371]

8 minutes ago, hexwin said:

You can NOT abuse the system very bad, because you awill not be posting public rfeedback, it will be private feedback that only you can see

I think most of the people is not really reading the entire idea since they are not reading much. (I personally is guilty about it, I also missed it however it does not happen to me very often).

As I said it is kinda personal note so there will be no abuse at all, I mean there are no scope for abuse of course.

Edited October 18, 2019 by xBDT Script

[hexwin 4931]

3 minutes ago, xBDT Script said:

I think most of the people is not really reading the entire idea since they are not reading much. (I personally is guilty about it, I also missed it however it does not happen to me very often).

As I said it is kinda personal note so there will be no abuse at all, I mean there are no scope for abuse of course.

Thanks. I edited first post and added information about 'private personal note part'
Maybe admin can introduce something similar when they show us some better reactions system also.
All in one package

[xBDT Script 4371]

3 hours ago, hexwin said:

This Feedback feature should be private only, and not public.

Yeah I see this LOL

3 minutes ago, hexwin said:

Maybe admin can introduce something similar when they show us some better reactions system also.

To me it does not matter at all (talking about the note for the users). I think we will need better issue to focus on at the moment. Such as:

Finding good people to moderate local boards and to have some local boards

Monitoring the spams 

May be adding a report summary section 

etc.

 

[hexwin 4931]

7 minutes ago, xBDT Script said:

To me it does not matter at all (talking about the note for the users). I think we will need better issue to focus on at the moment. Such as:

Finding good people to moderate local boards and to have some local boards

Monitoring the spams 

May be adding a report summary section 

etc.

 

Question is will admin ever add Local boards... as so far we heard nothing about it,
and I think russians are in huge advantage as they can write in two places and in their own language.

But I think this Feedback notes I suggested is also important.
I noticed many automated bots posting and I want to tag them all

5 minutes ago, vlc39 said:

but then what is the point of being private?

the point of feedback should be to know which user is trusted and legit and which are scammer.

if you have lots of feedbacks, maybe you are trusted, and without viewing this, who can know?

Point is that you can identify friends, good users , bot and spammers easy.

I would also propose some Friend feature, so I can add fa friend that is trusted.

 

Edited October 18, 2019 by hexwin

[xBDT Script 4371]

6 minutes ago, vlc39 said:

but then what is the point of being private?

the point of feedback

Well this is why I am not saying it feedback but it's a personal note to the user. It could be handy for some users say for example they want to write a short note about some of their fellow forum mates.

Say I have very good time with a member here and for some reason he left the forum for long time. Obviously the chances are that I may forget him. But after few years he come back then I can just see my note and can identify him.

This feature could be useless for few members though. But I can make it good use for it.

 

Just now, hexwin said:

Question is will admin ever add Local boards... as so far we heard nothing about it,

Hearing nothing about it does not mean that he is not considering it. Obviously a community will need people from around the world and it also needs moderators. I think the admin is trying to find the right balance before putting the local boards in action.

Edited October 18, 2019 by xBDT Script

[hexwin 4931]

2 minutes ago, xBDT Script said:

Well this is why I am not saying it feedback but it's a personal note to the user. It could be handy for some users say for example they want to write a short note about some of their fellow forum mates.

Say I have very good time with a member here and for some reason he left the forum for long time. Obviously the chances are that I may forget him. But after few years he come back then I can just see my note and can identify him.

I would also propose something like 'Add Friend' feature... so if you have trusted friend or member you can add him as your Friend.  No enemies 😉

[cryptokram 102]

8 minutes ago, vlc39 said:

but then what is the point of being private?

the point of feedback should be to know which user is trusted and legit and which are scammer.

If we will get the feedback in public then it might affect the community, or that might be an abuse! any users can do a feedback to anyone but that will be on the part of the 2 users to see. But i think there should also be on the moderators and in that case if the mods make the feedback to 1 user that should be available for public viewers.

(feed backs cannot be reported to the mods if it can then there should be a board for this! a solid evidence must be provided also)

58 minutes ago, dovproduc said:

Considering that there is no trading section yet, I don't see what that would be for. Maybe we should add new areas of the forum so people can do more stuff, and then add features like feedback

trading is just a part of that feed back system, and we have marketplace now to cover that.

[xBDT Script 4371]

4 minutes ago, vlc39 said:

well, i thought of feedback more like the trust from bitcointalk where you post a positive when trade is sucessfully and negative when user scam or spam.

Those of us who are from BitcoinTalk can have this confusion since we have seen it in action. But to me in this forum I do not like to see it. However if two person who traded any goods or service then hey can exchange their experience with each others. As a third person you and me has nothing to do with it unless we are going to trade with one of them.

3 minutes ago, hexwin said:

I would also propose something like 'Add Friend' feature... so if you have trusted friend or member you can add him as your Friend.  No enemies 😉

Well follow and ignore features are serving for the both 😊 I already have some ignored users LOL

Edited October 18, 2019 by xBDT Script

[hexwin 4931]

3 minutes ago, xBDT Script said:

Well follow and ignore features are serving for the both 😊 I already have some ignored users LOL

I have ignore members also... and yes we can use follow feature also, that is a good point, but then you will receive every notification from him I think

[xBDT Script 4371]

4 minutes ago, hexwin said:

but then you will receive every notification from him I think

The topics they create not the posts the makes. But isn't it the whole point of having the friends here. You would like to read their contents so you are following them.

Once can chose not to make it public though. I think I have this setting enabled LOL

[mostawda3 425]

A good idea will encourage members to make their publications of good value
Everyone will begin to add their opinion on the members, this will make the member looking for good assessments through good publications

[Kumar 260]

What you suggested is really good, if we could get the feedbacks then it would help the quality posters and spamers will have a hard time also they could get various offers based on it.

[Mohs3n71 0]

I think your idea can be integrated into the current method of giving reputations in this way that whenever someone wants to give a positive or negative reputation to anyone else he should also write some information about it

[hexwin 4931]

5 hours ago, Mohs3n71 said:

I think your idea can be integrated into the current method of giving reputations in this way that whenever someone wants to give a positive or negative reputation to anyone else he should also write some information about it

No it is not.
If you read slowly what I wrote it has nothing to do with current system.
Reaction are not text feedback and reactions are public.
Please read again.
Thank you

[cryptokram 102]

5 hours ago, Mohs3n71 said:

I think your idea can be integrated into the current method of giving reputations in this way that whenever someone wants to give a positive or negative reputation to anyone else he should also write some information about it

How you gonna send a user those reputation if there is not post made.

Like if we made a trade or i bought some Bitcoin to you then how can i give you the feed back on this?

There are different uses on reputation and feed back. i hope they can both  be in the forum!

[Saqib Ali Sadiq 438]

yes it is the best suggestion that there must be add feedback of the members which are working hard in the forum and making the forum more reliable they should be appreciated by giving them good feedback.

[hexwin 4931]

20 minutes ago, Richard said:

I do not agree with you because it will get a problem in this will resort to many users here to report anything For example, if you report someone or several people, they will resort to reporting anything that you publish as revenge.This is bad because your posts will be deleted if reported by several people

I wonder do you even read what I wrote or juste mumble down and write some words just so you write them?

We are not talking about any reports here.... go back and read first post please.

I am sick of reading posts like this that has nothing to do with topic!

[hexwin 4931]

3 minutes ago, Richard said:

( If someone is non-stop spamming me with fake conversation spam - I also want to write review for his profile )

with all my respect for you Who are you to write a review of the accounts of other members 

I am the master of the universe !

Hello!? Do you use one thing in your head called brain?

Feedback is P R I V A T E and only I can see it.

I don't know how you managed to be Member rank... 
but I know what feedback I would write for you, and only I know that

Edited October 25, 2019 by hexwin

[hexwin 4931]

1 minute ago, meowmeow said:

I think the feedback feature is good if it is on public instead. So that people are aware on how they really act in this kind of forum. I do not think it will become useful if we leave a feedback and no one can see it but only you and the other person whom you gave a feedback.

It is useful for me...so I know if someone I had traded before or if this person is posting offtopic all the time, or he is ignorant like Richard who can't even read english and post I wrote.
I would like to add my private feedback for them to recognise them in future

[hexwin 4931]

2 minutes ago, Richard said:

You can take a look at my analysis I don't need to give your opinion on my analysis Watch and keep quiet that is better for you

https://www.tradingview.com/u/WhalesTrader/

You should first learn to read and I don't care for your fake trading predictions and mambo jambo.
I will speak freely and you choose some of other topic to share your 'wisdom' 

[Geo 90]

Yeah its quiet interesting. Giving feedback about ones positive as well as negative really worth it.it also create interest among newbies like me...if anything said positive or it will be helpful to improve if anything said negative 

[hexwin 4931]

Just now, Richard said:

Didn't find what you say about my analysis to say go and learn to read hhhhh

It is better not to talk to you because you are not from my level 

Please stay on topic you self-proclaim whale.

Learn to read English language first and to understand what I is written,
then come back and talk what you learned in school

This topic is for Adding Private Feedback Note to Members only